xmlns:og='http://ogp.me/ns#' Yeah. Good Times.: A dog analogy

Wednesday, May 1, 2013

A dog analogy

Child 1 is afraid of dogs; irrationally and completely scared shitless. It doesn't matter the size or the temperament, he will walk the widest arc around even the sweetest, calmest dog in the world who is sleeping on the sidewalk, nevermind the happy-go-lucky-I-want-to-lick-your-face ones. He runs in abject terror when he encounters them, even as their owner explains "don't worry, she's friendly!" That doesn't help, friendly is even worse.  I've learned, over the years, to put my body in between a dog and him whenever we encounter one; if he's hiding behind me he won't feel the need to run into the street to get away from it (and he's done that).

Earlier today I was walking home from the store (by myself!! OMG!!) when I passed a house that had a dog inside a fenced in yard. This was one of those little yippy guys, with LOTS of energy, and he had very very strong opinions about the fact that I was walking past his yard. The yard, and the fence, was rather long, and as I walked by, he jumped and jumped, and ran back and forth, and barked his opinion at me quite forcefully. It was actually a little unnerving, even to me, but this guy was so small that even his highest possible jump only got him halfway up the height of the fence; there was no way he was getting out.

And I thought, as I walked by, that I was glad Child 1 wasn't with me, because even though he would have been physically safe, he would have been emotionally very upset by the experience. And then I thought that there were probably some people in the world who would complain to the person who lived there that they had an autistic child who was terrified of dogs and the owner needed to keep their dog inside so as to not upset their child.

Are there really people like that? I don't actually know (who knows, here in Berkeley. Probably). Regardless of how unreasonable this request is, however, it seems to be to be a good analogy for a manner of child raising in which I do not subscribe: that the world needs to bend for my child because he is autistic. That I have the right to place unreasonable demands on other people, and that I should expect other people to acquiesce to my unreasonable demands, because my child is autistic.

I don't think that is my role as a parent of an autistic child or even an NT child. I think my job is to prepare them for the world, the world as it is, not the other way around. If I just happen to have some spare time I can do my best to try to educate people about autism, but that's all I can do. I can't expect other people to change for my son, but I can expect to teach him to prepare for them. The world may not be a completely fair and happy place, but it's my job, as his mother, to make sure he enters the world with the tools and the fortitude in order to deal with it. 

I have no right to ask the dog owner to keep his dog inside, but I do have the right, and the ability, and the presence of mind, to cross to the other side of the street so that my son can still make his way down the road.



Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
KidsDrDave's avatar

KidsDrDave · 621 weeks ago

Yep
I feel this way too. I also think that for those who do believe it is possible and acceptable to insist everyone else change to better suit their child, that even they have to acknowledge and work within the reality that it will take decades to force and create this sort of change, so they still have to help the child learn how to function in a less-than-ideal reality.
i was not gonna leave a comment just to make you punch a kitten, but then i thought--i'm trying to force you to deal with my need to kitten violence. and that is wrong of me.

you have taught me a valuable life lesson.
1 reply · active 621 weeks ago
OMG I love you
I think I agree with you. I'm just having weird acceptance/awareness PTSD issues today for some reason. I'm having a difficult time getting my thoughts in order.
Perfect analogy. (without the ogy on that, it's 'perfect anal'). I see this in both the Down syndrome and autism communities. We can do our best so that there are accommodations made, just like crossing the street here, but the world isn't going to change to meet the needs of the minority. This has NEVER been the case.
I wholeheartedly agree. Our job is to prepare them for the world. If you do it the other way around, there's no way to prepare the world for them.
I agree. I see my role as parent is to teach my kids about the world, the rules, the cultural norms. The fact some of this stuff is particularly hard for them means I need to be mindful of that, and to help people like their teachers also understand and make accommodations, but the allowances I make does not mean I don't keep teaching them. The label of autism doesnt mean I don't have expectations of my kids. The world is always going to be a busy, chaotic place, I'm teaching my kids to negotiate that as best they can. That's my job.
Here is where I will tell one of my Autism Stories™ (I know you just can't wait!)

My first "real" job out of college was taking a student with Asperger's Syndrome to his college classes (based on the newest DSM, I think Asperger's "isn't autism anymore" or something, but that's another can of worms). This individual shared Child 1's terrible fear of dogs. I'm grateful that, though people can and do raise Guiding Eyes for the Blind puppies on that campus, we never encountered one when I was on watch. I mostly learned about his fear through discussion (As he had absorbed that he was supposed to use his I statements in that way, and speak about himself on occasion), and from his mother learned that he used to be far more afraid than he was by the time I met him. They had cats, by the by. I don't think this matters to the story.

Well. I discovered the hard way I wasn't suited to such work (thankfully, I took it out on those around me at home, as opposed to my....client? Student? Whichever). That's when I went to work at the library. Subsequent years later, I got Elka, blah blah blah.

So, the point of my story is that I saw said individual one day with one of his newer aides whilst I was out walking Elka. We were on the way home from the park (Thank God!) and I stopped to say hi to him (while telling her "move over", so she'd be away from him). He greeted me, and then greeted the dog, who sniffed him in a mellow way and that was that! The next time I saw his mother, I told her. She hadn't even heard the story, as apparently the newest aide wasn't familiar with his previous dog fear. So. I was proud of him, and so was she.

But, even as a dog owner (or perhaps ESPECIALLY as a dog owner) I hate it when people allow their dogs to ballistically bark and fence race like that. Barrier frustration is not a good thing, and frequently results in a bite by the dog somewhere down the line (I guess I should be glad said dog isn't chained?)
I totally agree! But since you set the analogy, i have a short rant -- people who own dogs, I don't care how cute or friendly "fluffy" is, keep the damn thing under control when out in public. Just because you're enamored by your beast doesn't mean everyone else wants your dog jumping on them, etc. (signed dog lover/owner -- and runner regularly "accosted" by other's dogs).
I completely agree with you. It is our job as parents to teach our kids as best as we can how to live in a world that will not bend to them. We can't expect anyone to bend to anyone else's needs so we teach our kids. My son Buddy is a prime example - he cannot tolerate elevators. I mean HE CANNOT TOLERATE ELEVATORS. Not all buildings have stairs that are accessible to the pubic (only emergency stairs) so I sometimes have to make him go in the elevator. Am I supposed to call management and say they need to make the stairs available just because my son can't tolerate them? All I can do is teach him that elevators are okay and work on visual focus and deep compressions to help him through the ride.
If every parent agreed with your stance that

"I think my job is to prepare them for the world, the world as it is, not the other way around. If I just happen to have some spare time I can do my best to try to educate people about autism, but that's all I can do. I can't expect other people to change for my son, but I can expect to teach him to prepare for them. The world may not be a completely fair and happy place, but it's my job, as his mother, to make sure he enters the world with the tools and the fortitude in order to deal with it. "

then I think this world would be a better place. Parents spend too much time trying to manipulate the world for their children, autistic or not. And that's really not the way life works.
Dogs smogs.

Can we talk about the incorrectness of your Labels (<---- over there). Last time I checked, there were 52 Fridays a year (sometimes 53 right!?) and you only have 14 "I'm Drunk" tags. And only 12 about Target. Or is that just for one week!? See how it can be confusing.

P.S. I'm baaaaaaaack although I'm not exactly sure where I was...

Besos, Sarah
Blogger at Journeys of The Zoo
i fully agree to this. there are things that can be accommodated and changed for our children, and there are things that cannot but where we should be able to help our child to adapt. I would not want to attract the wrath of certain parents but 'helicopter parenting' and entitlement attitude for children with special needs can totally backfire when it comes to acceptance in the broad public. Especially for the 'invisible' handicaps of kids with autism.
first of all: i saved a kitten, refer to statement below post a comment area

yes i think the reason why children are afraid of dogs is that their bark can be unnerving even if its a friendly one, and i have to admit sometimes dog barks can be rather annoying and loud even for adults

Post a new comment

Comments by