When Child 1 was in preschool and we were preparing for Kindergarten, I saw a post on a local mailing list written by a mom with a kid in Special Ed (SPED) asking what parents thought about the district's Inclusion Program, and worrying how other parents felt about it, etc. The majority of responses were positive, parents, in general, are able to appreciate the differentness in everybody and had good things to say about their experiences. Some responses were not so positive, though. Parents (nobody had the balls to sign their name, of course) said that SPED kids "stole" resources away from General Ed (GenEd) kids; in today's tough times, with budgets so tight, it "wasn't fair" that their kids were losing teacher time and resources because the district thought it was politically correct to put the SPED kids in the with the rest of them. Seriously. Someone said that.
So, Child 1, and myself, enter public elementary school knowing that people feel this way. (Okay, Child 1 doesn't know and even if he did he probably wouldn't care, it was just me that knew this) and at first I was afraid to even mention that he had a disability, but as the years have gone on I realize that there's a pretty good crew of folks at the school and I haven't much encountered that attitude. PHEW!
However, here's what I've learned about SPED and GenEd resources at our district that I wish I could have told myself, and those jackass other parents from the mailing list 5 years ago.
- Our district was apparently the birth place of Special Education; there was once a fantastic program, designed by parents, teachers and administrators, that actually fully included SPED kids and provided them the support they needed to get them an education. Awesome!
- SPED is federally funded. Services are paid for by a separate budget within the district, money which comes from the federal government, authorized by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act of 2004.
- Federal law (IDEA and NCLB) requires that districts adopt a "Response to Intervention" program which tries to identify kids who are struggling and get them extra help before they fall too far behind and instead of a referral to SPED. This is actually a good idea, don't you think? I think so. Not being sarcastic, I think that's really a good idea.
- The Department of Education has allowed school districts to use 15% of IDEA funding for early intervention services in regular education
Over time, though, our district has been moving away from the great inclusion program in favor of the RTI program which attempts to address the needs of all kids. They've been doing this, though, by taking already strapped SPED staff and basically just giving them extra work with extra kids. After all, they can use 15% of their IDEA budget to pay for their RTI, so why not just tack on some extra duties to the Resource staff already there? So what happened is that the Inclusion Coordinator became the Resource Coordinator, and while on paper the district said "you're 85% SPED and 15% GenEd" the reality is that she no longer has 30 or so kids with IEPs on her caseload, she now has every kid at the school on her caseload, about 400. Because every kid at the school is entitled to an "intervention" if they need it, or at least a referral, to the Resource Coordinator. (I'm not sure if that's her actual title, I don't remember)
My kid's disability manifests itself in the classroom by him sitting quietly, softly talking to himself, looking beautiful and doing an excellent job pretending to be paying attention, but not learning a single thing unless there's somebody standing over his shoulder the whole time. He has an aide (Federally funded!!) and there are a host of GenEd kids who are a huge disruption to the classroom. These kids don't have IEPs and I have no idea if they need one or not, but as they act out, the teacher, and my son's aide, are forced to turn their attention to those kids, while mine sits quietly, looking beautiful and not learning. Those GenEd kids, who don't have a 504 or an IEP, get referred to the Resource Coordinator as head of the Intervention team, because they're falling behind. Because the Resource Coordinator is now so strapped for time, I have a great deal of trouble even getting an IEP meeting scheduled. It's not her fault, she's doing the best she can, she just has way too much to do.
So, the bottom line, and I say this to the myself of five years ago, or anybody else who doesn't know any better, or anybody with a child in SPED entering a public school: At our district, it is actually the General Ed kids who steal resources and teacher time away from the Special Ed kids. In today's tough times, when budgets are so tight, it's really not fair that a federally funded program should be drained away by kids who don't qualify for it. Oh, yeah, that's right, I went there.
Claire · 682 weeks ago
My recent post Still Searching
Sarah @ The Fence · 682 weeks ago
My recent post Sunday Funday #25
Rards · 682 weeks ago
dixieredmond 35p · 682 weeks ago
Tessa · 682 weeks ago
Mama Meerkat · 682 weeks ago
My recent post Happy Spring
Mom2MissK 74p · 682 weeks ago
My recent post Meme Candy: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Me
Lizbeth · 682 weeks ago
My recent post The Vengaboys have taken over my bathroom and do they like to party.
Jim Reeve · 682 weeks ago
And it seems that sometimes GENED parents are in need of some SPED themselves.
jentroester 36p · 682 weeks ago
I have never observed K's classroom (I actually will be next month), so I can't speak to whether or not there are a bunch of gen ed kids using all the resources. Now I will be looking for this since the class aide is supposed to be dedicated to K for most of the day, per her IEP. One problem we have is that there are like 28 kids in K's class, with the ONE teacher and then the ONE aide for K...I assume she doesn't spend as much time with K as she should b/c a bunch of 2nd graders are probably wild and I doubt the one teacher can handle them all, all the time.
People need to realize, spec ed gets a lot of it's own money from the govt. It's not a program that is sending schools to the poorhouse. It's just the shitty economy and schools making stupid decisions (like our town that closed down an elementary school and it ended up costing them millions more to do that than it would have to leave it open...smh). I hope to get the balls to run for school committee, b/c the yahoos we have in their now suck.
My recent post Special Olympics
J.D. · 682 weeks ago
My recent post Wordless Wednesday
Kim · 682 weeks ago
They really needed a baseball coach. It's all about priorities, people.
In his new school, he has flourished. There are about 30 boys in the entire program, all of them pretty much like him.
He has a friend.!
A friend who is kind and cooperative - and I can slowly see The Boy parroting some of this behavior.
It rocks, the teachers are excellent, and in this year, I have NEVER been called to come pick him up for behavior problems.
He's learning stuff, and learning how to get along with people. If I could clone the entire program, and offer it world-wide.
Sure, I'm probably exaggerating a wee bit, but seriously, this is the best program he's ever been in. I sit and think about how his education might have gone if he had had the opportunity to be in the program since elementary school.
My recent post On Leading a Charmed Life
blogginglily 73p · 682 weeks ago
My recent post The Audition
Tee Eff Tee · 682 weeks ago
In order to comply with the zeitgeist, public schools had to indicate, however loosely, that they were doing everything they could for their low SES kids who were not SPED.
And, now you have what Jill describes--a room in the school staffed by an overworked specialist who is responsible for the whole fucking school, as if teachers can't deal with their kids. Oh, and they go to the room--they get pulled out.
RTI and in BUSD, ULYSES (or whatever they call it) are a scam to make people feel like they are "responding" with an "intervention" when all they are doing is flailing in a new room.
We need to fund our schools properly, and this will all go away.
And remember, in California, to opt out of the state test, all you need to do is inform your school that your child WILL NOT take the test. When they ask you why or try to scare you, just look them in the eye, calmly, and restate your intention to opt your kid out, and then say, "Okay? Good."
Don't be intimidated. Your kid ain't their fucking tool.
K. (G's Mom) · 682 weeks ago
BUT - our school district uses the test results to determine which middle and high schools you an go to. Sigh. What can I do?
My recent post Got a new phone...not that I'll ever get to use it.
deerhart23 11p · 682 weeks ago
Mind you my kids have always been mainstreamed and we wouldn't allow placement anywhere else. We have had awesome school districts and one of the most unique Special Education setups in the country for my kid's preschool through 5th grade <a href="http://(http://www.ssdmo.org/" target="_blank">(http://www.ssdmo.org/ county wide and covers all 24 school districts in the county). Because of that we had to coordinate dates for IEPs for both of us, reg teacher, resource teacher, school VP, School district regional rep, Speech, School Counselor, SSD regional rep, plus any other extra people we needed (yes that was a minimum of 9 people) and it also meant that SSD controlled placement of SPED teachers in the school, not the school (so the school got limited say in personnel changes)
We were very happy to start limiting pullouts starting in about 4th grade and both the old school and the new school had no pullouts planned for 6th grade (they both do speech in the main classrooms at the level).
Now I do disagree slightly that SPED doesn't pull resources from the general budget. While the do get federal funds for SPED, in general, those funds are not sufficient to cover all SPED costs. They help, but when you have a school that must offer the child ALL services, regardless of costs, and the federal funds are only so much per child. So it hurts even more when you funnel those funds away from SPED to RTI programs because your dealing with a limited budget but unlimited costs.
My recent post How to Survive Until My Social Security Disability Benefits are Approved Pt 2 – Housing
jillsmo 103p · 682 weeks ago
deerhart23 11p · 682 weeks ago
jillsmo 103p · 682 weeks ago
Sent from my Blackberry. Sorry about the typos.
@MostlyTrueStuff · 682 weeks ago
What worries me is that in saying that the resources are being drained by the regular kids, that schools will take that AND RUN...meaning wanting to do LESS inclusion and saying it's for the sake of the child. UG. You can't win either way.
K. (G's Mom) · 682 weeks ago
I have seen the class size in my son's special needs preschool room double in just the last month. I am there every single day, and I can't keep track of their names. There is a teacher and two aides in the room, but the district is trying to get rid of the aides.
Meanwhile - the school just hired two new RTI teachers to serve the gen-ed classrooms.
My recent post Got a new phone...not that I'll ever get to use it.
Cactusinyrpants 59p · 682 weeks ago
jillsmo 103p · 682 weeks ago
Cactusinyrpants 59p · 682 weeks ago
jillsmo 103p · 682 weeks ago
Cactusinyrpants 59p · 682 weeks ago